This week Emily and the three remaining bachelors journeyed to the Caribbean island of Curacao. Emily had individual dates with each of the guys: a helicopter ride with Sean, a sailboat ride with Jef, and swimming in the ocean with Arie. She talked with each of them about their future together, lifestyle, and whether they were ready to get engaged and become a father figure to Emily’s daughter, Ricky. For the first time in Bachelor history, Emily chose NOT to stay in the “Fantasy Suite” with any of the men because she didn’t think it was appropriate, and she wants to be a good role model for her daughter.
Emily watched video messages from each of the guys and started crying, realizing she was going to end up hurting one of them. In a moment of awkward silence, she said goodbye to Sean, asking HIM to say something. (Shouldn’t she be the one doing the explaining??) Sean was devastated, saying that he really thought Emily would end up his wife. But with his overly-confident grin, it was always hard to tell if he truly had genuine feelings for her. Find out his side of the story, along with the rest of the rejects, next week on The Men Tell All.